Monday, May 23, 2005

Analysis:
Fire and Seeds

This is a college town: a private college, a state university, something marginally better than a diploma mill, and a community college are all located within about a five-mile radius.

The town is divided into the visible, reputable, upper-middle class and the less visible, but far larger, class that isn't. The better people for the most part work in middle or upper management at one of the several huge, multi-national services companies in town. Everyone else gets by. The layoffs at the big factories on the outskirts of town have left a quiet wasteland of older people trying to find work and younger people trying to find a future.

The bright kids from the right side of the tracks go to the state university, or they leave town entirely. The rest of the kids find work where they can, and many of them stop by the community college on their way to adulthood. They join the ranks of older people taking classes because they, like the youthful students, believe that the key to a job—a real job with permanence and benefits and meaning—lies in education. Many of them, young and old alike, vow to go on to the state university to complete four-year degrees. Most won't.

The people who attend the community college are, for the most part, trying to lay patches on a shambles of the education they have already received. Young and old together find the task terribly difficult. Studying productively hours at a time is just not in their nature and not in their backgrounds. Attending classes every day isn't either. Showing up for exams is not an absolute. Cheating is not a matter of ethical proscription; it's just a matter of not getting caught. The community college sells them all a bill of goods, and some rise to the challenge, but others simply cannot. At best, though, from this place will come some graduates who will go on to the state university or to a technical school and eventually get a job that pays a marginally living wage.

Between the old and new wings of the main building where classes are conducted is a big smoking area. There, the people gather; and there, the conversations among the students paint a broad canvas of the lives these people have and the lives to which they aspire.

So much of what the young men talk about is war. Many are already in the Guard, or they are about to enlist, or they're back from a tour of duty. They talk about other things; but a great swath of what animates their conversations has to do with war. With their culturally acceptable crew cuts and they're almost uniform-like clothing, they go on and on about war.

Three young men are talking out there, and the one young man, who's just enlisted, says, "Fuck, yeah. I'd fucking shoot 'em. They shit on themselves! Did you hear about that?—they shit on themselves when you lock 'em up!" The other two are snickering and nodding their heads in agreement.

Another young man—every bit the square-jaw, flat-top, muscles-on-top-of-muscles Marine—sucks hard on the butt of his cigarette while he grumbles about the female soldiers in his company having sex with their superiors, then refusing to do any work, and no one will punish them. He gets off that subject and starts talking about how the Marines don't do bad things and screw up all the time like the Army people do: Marines are disciplined, trained warriors; and Army people are nothing but a bunch of worthless junk that never thought they'd actually have to do anything for their weekend-warrior paychecks and college grant money. His eyes brighten when he's asked about weaponry. "You guys didn't have the 'Saw' back then, did you?" he grins. A little prompting gets him to describe it: sort of a cross between an M-16 and an M-60. "It's sweet."

He doesn't even make it to the final exam before his unit's called back. An early, hastily written final gets him the "A" he probably didn't quite deserve.

A slightly older student is always out there before and after class. He's a full-fledged veteran. As the semester goes on, his struggle to find a job takes a more and more noticeable toll on his demeanor. He stops talking about what he wants to major in when he goes to the state university. He talks more and more about how good it felt to be out in the field, to be among his buddies, to be among weapons with their awe-inspiring power. By the end of the semester, he's gone to the recruiting station to cut a deal to re-enlist.

Another veteran isn't too talkative. Outside in the smoking area, he stays mostly to himself, but sometimes he'll talk about his truck and his new son. He chain smokes while he sits, leaning forward with his hands on his knees, staring out across the corn fields beside the campus. At one point, after all the other kids have gone inside for their next classes, he takes one last draw on his cigarette, and he mutters something about what a couple of young, loud pups were saying.


The culture of these males just oozes a deepening affinity to what the neo-conservatives have done to re-tool America into a war nation. The economy is failing them, the world of high and broad knowledge is pretty much unavailable to them, and the prospect of a country at peace is uninteresting to them. But despite all that should be telling them to fight for change, to insist upon and demand a civil society that provides abundantly for its people, these men line up to embrace the very mentality that sets upon them the boot of want and despair.

This time of war is what gives those young men their meaning, their hope, their focus. It's all an abstraction to people of better means: it's flag-waving nationalism for America on the march, or it's wholesale revulsion at the lies breeding the monstrosity of it all. But for the kids there at that community college, it's the way out of the slow stew of economic and social Hell that awaits them in lives that promise to otherwise go nowhere and mean nothing.

There's some of this at the state university, too; but there's something else going on, and it's even evident in small ways at the community college. It's very much like the mid-1960s: most of the kids wear their hair butch-cut short and talk a fairly hard conservative line while doing a whole lot of unconservative things. At first blush, everyone looks just about the same as everyone else.

But then, there's that fringe group.

Looking closely at the young people scurrying between the buildings, shock of all shocks, long hair on a few young men is making a comeback. So is that avoidance of the tough-talk boy groups in the smoking areas and the hallways. So is that almost cautious, imperceptible excitement of engagement when they realize that the professor is unapologetically and unrelentingly chewing into the dominant media's perspectives on what's happening in the world.

Once in a while, they'll even let a professor in on their political activism: underground newspapers, blogs, the coffee shop where they get together. They don't talk too openly, but they know what they're doing. They're dabbling in all things counterculture: anarchism; Marxism; strangely defiant music; variant art and comics; and even deconstructive intellectualism, that thing to which they were denied exposure throughout their entire educational experiences. They're exploring themes and people and places and ideas that no one in their entire lives told them existed; and the more they learn, the more their alienation is channeling. Yes, some of this has been going on all along; but now, the faint smell of critical mass is in the air. It's still a long journey from here to where the open clashes start to come.

But come they will. And they will be every bit as nation-wrenching as the last time the kids got sick of the lies and did something about it. All the older people can do is sit back and choose a side. Or maybe be a professor who shows up at the coffee house to listen to them as they become the hope of a better future.

And about what that quiet veteran muttered, the one who didn't talk much except about his truck and his new son: he'd been listening to a couple of young men nearby blabbing excitedly about their recent enlistments and going over to Iraq. What the veteran muttered was, "Dumb-asses."


So it begins. And we all know where it ends.






The Dark Wraith has spoken.

<< 41 Comments Total
 DuWayne Brayton blogged...

Just a few short years ago I lived entirely in that fringe. i hope and pray they get as loud and out there as I and my compatriots were, wehn there was less to be loud and angry about. As I prepare to move out west I am spending a little time at my parents house. I went downtown just yesterday and visited the coffe shops (the ones still around) that I haunted about 4 years ago. Many of the same sort of kids were there, but it was quiet. You could actually hear the music clearly. Four years ago you wouldn't have. People sat around getting into heated debates, laughing loudly with their friends. People were alive with rage, angst and excitement. Now they act as though they are in a library. I found the same thing last week when I visited the cafe's in East Lansing. I really hope they wake up and express their anger.

I have been torn by having a son. I recently decided it is more important for me to be more active in trying to induce change in my nation. i have hesitated because it is a very real possability that our government may go all the way over the deep end and round up the dissidents. My son needs a dad wh is not in jail but more importantly my son needs a country where he really does have the freedom to grow and be free. The fact that I have to fear being imprisoned for trying to regain the freedoms that were stripped from us and given to the terrorists that attacked our nation is the catalyst that has pushed me closer to civil disobedience.

My lovely friend Elizabeth once told me that in protests, those with children should hold back from protesting their way into jail. Let those with less responsability take care of that part of it. The sad fact is that not enough people who fall into that latter catagory feel motivated enough to accept those risks. When I was younger I was jailed on three occasions for civil disobedience at protests. I can't afford to go to jail any more but for my son's sake I can't afford not to.

Mon May 23, 10:29:23 AM EDT  
 oldwhitelady blogged...

That's so damn depressing - I'm just about ready to cry.

Mon May 23, 11:51:08 AM EDT  
 Anonymous blogged...

The veteran understands the comment once uttered during the Civil War about it being a good thing that war was so awful, lest we grow to love it too much.

I see a lot of this as a grievous and unwanted side effect of discontinuing the draft. Compulsory conscription isn't the right thing to do in my mind, but I also believe that NOT having it has resulted in warmongering becoming a spectator sport among the vast majority of Americans.

This is wrong.

- oddjob

Mon May 23, 12:07:08 PM EDT  
 Anonymous blogged...

Oh, yes, I've noticed long hair seems to be making a comeback among the "arty" ones. It's been striking to me to notice 18 year olds wearing their hair the way that was widespread when I was 18.

- oddjob

Mon May 23, 01:52:14 PM EDT  
 Mr. Shakes blogged...

Afternoon, all.

Great Post. I'm with oddjob on this question of the military draft. Although in my bones I dislike the idea of a draft, I think it could prove benefical for a couple of reasons.

As oddjob said, it would certainly concentrate the minds of those who think war is fun, as they will know that they themsleves or one of their loved ones may be forced to ante up. The prospect of a draft would certainly make these people think a little harder about who they vote for.

Now, this may prove a little controversial, but I think there is another reason why a draft may be a good thing: volunteer armies that have been trained only for combat are not proving very effective in the peacekeeper role. Sending an army of testosterone fueled xenophobes who have been trained for one purpose only: to kill, to manage a powder keg like Iraq is (and was) a very, very bad idea. The Pentagon itself is considering the creation of a two tier army: one tier for combat, another for peacekeeping missions. Although the peacekeepers would be trained to defend themselves, their main skills would be in linguistics, policework and diplomacy.

Perhaps this is the answer. A volunteer army for combat, and a peacekeeping force drafted from the general populace, and trained in cultural studies, diplomacy, etc, to handle the aftermath.

I understand that there are caveats: the army that fought in Vietnam was drafted, for example. But, hell, I dunno - we've got to try something.

If we really must do the whole Empire thing then thet's at least be smart about it.

Mon May 23, 03:21:13 PM EDT  
 Mr. Shakes blogged...

Ah, yes. Thet's be smart about it.

Oops!

Mon May 23, 03:23:54 PM EDT  
 PoliShifter blogged...

God save our country and its people from the NeoCons.

Mon May 23, 03:25:19 PM EDT  
 oldwhitelady blogged...

Dear Dark, do you mind if I call you by your first name?

I didn't go and cry after reading it, but as I noted earlier, I felt like it. Your poignant, yet beautifully written, 'Analysis:
Fire and Seeds' subjects could be located at many colleges through the land. The description of the Community College reminded me of my experiences at college - my classmates and I (most of us) had full time jobs, as well as class at night. It was a trying time for many, but I'm sure it was nothing like what the students must go through, now.

In reading and understanding the cards of life these students are dealt, we can figure out why some would be pro-war. Because of the lack of jobs available to them, they see no other option but to enlist. To feel good about the upcoming tour of duty, they need to brainwash themselves into believing what they do is right, no matter how they might have felt before signing up.

Articles mentioning military background usually catch my eye, when describing some sort of violent crime against family or others. I often think that this violence is partially, if not fully, created by being exposed to the violence of war.

Mon May 23, 03:25:29 PM EDT  
 Kat blogged...

I'm not old enough to remember Vietnam, but I know the toll it took on my Dad, who has a Purple Heart for his service, and the toll it took on our country. It would appear that history does repeat itself. As my Dad says "It's a damn shame we didn't learn our lesson the first time."

Mon May 23, 05:39:37 PM EDT  
 Anonymous blogged...

There's a case to be made that this wouldn't be happening if we hadn't set up "universal" conscription in the non-universal way that it was done back then. Almost all the planners of this ill-begotten idea were of the age that they would have gone had they not found deferrments of one sort or another.

- oddjob

Mon May 23, 07:41:45 PM EDT  
 My Pet Goat blogged...

Excellent point Oddjob, but in bush's case deferrment is too polite of a substitute for the word AWOL.

Mon May 23, 08:33:29 PM EDT  
 Anonymous blogged...

I don't deny the AWOL (although I'm not a lawyer, so I don't have to think about it being proven in a court of law, where I might be more circumspect). I was referring to his daddy swinging the Natl. Guard assignment for him.

- oddjob

Mon May 23, 08:51:21 PM EDT  
 Me4Prez blogged...

I have hung out with the wealthy and then gone home to an alcoholic father and working 60 hours a week to pay tuition. I guess I always had hope though because I did walk among the advantaged even though I wasn't myself. I have always been the kid who crossed the tracks to go to private schools though. I was never really accepted, but never really turned away either.

I think that is why I am for some type of mandatory service and would probably even accept a draft if it was actually fair and noone was exempt because of social status. I agree that it would change the minds of many who supported the war but often asked me, "will my son/daughter be drafted, because i don't want them to fight in it."

I have called many people dumbasses who think the war is good and believe the propaganda without hesitation. From guys currently in who I served with to guys who think it would be cool to go to war. I have never been in combat and never really wanted to be. I knew I could and accepted that, but wouldn't have partied if I finally got my "chance to go."

I normally don't disagree with much Mr Shakes says, but I disagree that it is because they only trained for war that they are having problems. As a former soldier, I think it is because they don't really train for anything. There is a lot of training, but I often said in after action reviews that we trained to look good fighting, but not to fight well. The leadership sucks and many are volunteers are there for the wrong reason and are never really trained for the real possibilities of combat. It is always possible, but noone ever took the thought seriously when I was in.

Mon May 23, 10:10:16 PM EDT  
 The Educated Eclectic blogged...

I posted this comment at Big Brass Blog, but I would like to copy it here, as the thread is large:

I have taught at the community college, psychology, for the past couple of years...it is truly amazing how many of my students read nary a newspaper or saw little or no news on tv. In their jalopies they would listen to music (xtra bass) but never a talk radio station...

I made it mandatory to bring some sort of "current event" to class - by the end of the semester it is interesting to see how they became aware of how much they had been missing...

Mon May 23, 10:31:24 PM EDT  
 Ron Brynaert blogged...

The Dark Wraith sure can write.

Thanks for the great read...and the hopeful optimism at the end.

Tue May 24, 12:10:05 AM EDT  
 roger blogged...

as a non-vet old enough to have lived thru the 60s, i am heartened by the wraith's analysis. i like mr shakes suggestions. i think national service after high school is a good idea. i don't quite know what to think of the volunteer army, but i do see that the military is, for many young people, the best of a poor set of choices.

we don't suppose that it is part of a direct plan to ruin the economy so that the military is the only real option for the less educated and privileged do we? why, that would be downright cynical

Tue May 24, 12:48:05 AM EDT  
 Dark Wraith blogged...

Good evening, Dead Pirate Roberts.

To propose that the neo-conservatives would deliberately construct an economic environment that forces the poor into military service truly is cynical.

Very cynical.



The Dark Wraith likes cynicism.

Tue May 24, 02:09:36 AM EDT  
 Dark Wraith blogged...

Goood evening, Ron.

Although I strive to avoid optimism at every possible opportunity, I've seen too many signs lately that the pot is beginning to stir in a way that wasn't there even during the Presidential Election last year. It seems to me that part of what is propelling this is the blogs and the availability of communication channels on the Internet and in telecommunications; but I don't think that's the whole story.

There's something deeper going on, perhaps the "antithesis" that is the inevitable response to a new thesis that has been laid down by the political and religious Right. I am wondering if there will be a parallel religious antithesis showing up. I haven't seen much evidence of it, though.

One way or the other, it looks like an intellectual force is beginning to amass, and it's doing so in an exquisitely anarchistic way: there's no central direction motivating it; and it doesn't have any core of financial backing. That means it will, in due time, become far more robust and enduring than what the Right can sustain, given its utter dependence upon figureheads and big money.


The Dark Wraith always looks forward to a clash of barbarians and noblemen.

Tue May 24, 02:18:55 AM EDT  
 Dark Wraith blogged...

Good evening, Ms. Julien.

I spend more time than I probably should on current events in economics classes. My big challenge is, however, getting students up to speed on relatively recent history. I had one very bright student last semester who was absolutely shocked by the mention I made of a major attack within the United States that was thwarted during the Clinton Administration. He went outside and breathlessly asked his friends if any of them had ever heard of the Millenium Plot to blow up LAX. They didn't seem even the slightest bit interested in hearing what he had to say. That, of course, got him even more wound up. ("What th' Hell is this? Does everyone wanna be stupid, or something?!")

That has to be one of my favorite moments of the past year or so: seeing someone getting completely annoyed by the apathy of his peers.

That young man says he's thinking of switching his major from accounting to economics.

Poor bastard.



The Dark Wraith should probably try to repair the damage he's done to that fellow.

Tue May 24, 02:28:28 AM EDT  
 Dark Wraith blogged...

Good evening, Scott.

I have to agree with you that military training provides little in the way of anything other than total fear and some physical improvement, although neither of those lasts very long.

I remember some guys in "permanent party" who would deliberately go past the boot camp areas and yell obscenities at the drill sergeants who were, themselves, screaming obscenities at the trainees. It was sort of a game to see how close you could get without having one of the DIs decide to try to chase you. I never did it myself because I wasn't all that interested in testing my ability to outrun an insanely violent man wearing a stupid-looking hat.

Your point, however, is well taken. The obsession with order and drill, which goes all the way back to Roman times, has proven not very reliable as a means for broadly training soldiers in a world as complicated as the one we now have. The old model did work quite well for the Romans, of course; but as I've pointed out before, America might fancy itself the New Roman Empire, but it just isn't.

For one thing, NASCAR racing just doesn't compare to a real chariot race; and for another, football doesn't hold a candle to a real gladiator match.



The Dark Wraith longs for the good old days.

Tue May 24, 02:42:11 AM EDT  
 Dark Wraith blogged...

Good evening, Old White Lady.

With regard to domestic violence and veterans, imagine what it's like to be a soldier recently (or even not so recently) discharged from the service.

One day, you're expected to be a violent, order-taking, order-giving engine that can kill, cuss, scream, and do all manner of harm; and then, your weapon and all of the other tools you have learned to use for power are taken from you, and you're told to be a civilian and never act like this again.

It's really hard to turn yourself into a plaster saint when you've built your manhood from blood and dirt.

It's not impossible; it's just really hard.



The Dark Wraith wishes we had lots of better building blocks for boys to become adults.

Tue May 24, 02:49:17 AM EDT  
 Dark Wraith blogged...

Good evening, Mr. Shakes.

Your suggestion and the follow-up comments of OddJob and the others have prompted me to prepare a Forum Poll on the possibility of a return to universal conscription.

My suspicion is that the neo-conservatives are going to do everything within their power to avoid a draft, and they will do so because they know that would be a powerful focal point for rebellion against them and their plans.

The honest truth is that the armed forces are beyond the point, now, where a draft is needed. Unfortunately, beyond the neo-cons' aversion to it, I suspect that the military is in no way prepared at this point to put the resources into a major influx of new trainees that would necessarily pour into the services with a draft.

On the other hand, though, if one of a couple of hot spots boils over in the next few months, we'll be seeing some fairly sober voices talking more seriously about the draft.

And I'll tell you right now, that's going to turn a quietly building opposition to the neo-cons into a full-blown rebellion.


The Dark Wraith gets ready to sell pitchforks and torches.

Tue May 24, 02:58:08 AM EDT  
 Dark Wraith blogged...

And good evening, Treban.

Concerning protests that get you arrested, perhaps I can paraphrase the words of one wiser than I in the ways of combat.

The point is not for you to die for your country;
the point is for your enemy to die for
his.


Or, as has been my way since my less discreet days when I merrily volunteered to get my head bashed in at protests, consider my own little saying:

It is only when the hunted becomes the hunter that the latter finally learns the terror in the heart of the former.


The Dark Wraith likes a table that turns once in a while.

Tue May 24, 03:08:11 AM EDT  
 Anonymous blogged...

Another of the miserable Republican examples of this kind of hypocrisy is that miserable Texan retired Senator Phil Graham, who was born in a military hospital, raised as an army brat, went through college (including his econ. PhD) with abundant govt. assistance, and then went on to a legislative career characterized by excoriation of relying upon the government teat to get through one's life.

That econ. studying provided him with his deferment from 'nam of course....

- oddjob

Tue May 24, 09:09:09 AM EDT  
 PeterofLoneTree blogged...

"The point is not for you to die for your country;
the point is for your enemy to die for his".

Gen. George Patton?

Tue May 24, 09:27:39 AM EDT  
 Dark Wraith blogged...

Good morning, OddJob.

That the good Senator obtained a deferment based upon his studies in economics is yet further evidence economics is a good and useful college major. I shall admit, though, that it's a pity Dr. Graham didn't have the opportunity to do some field research in the supply and demand dynamics of death and destruction.

Perhaps if we revitalize the draft, we can retroactively rescind the deferments of the current breed of neo-con, acadmic hawks so they can finally have the chance to collect some battlefield data of their very own.



The Dark Wraith looks forward to watching those folks try to make it through basic training.

Tue May 24, 10:34:49 AM EDT  
 Dark Wraith blogged...

Good morning, Peter of Lone Tree.

Yes, that was supposedly said by General Patton. Although a violent pig of a human being, he did have a way with words on occasion.



The Dark Wraith appeciates a succinct statement of objectives.

Tue May 24, 10:37:19 AM EDT  
 My Pet Goat blogged...

This has been floating around on the internet for some time now and makes for a good comparison between parties. Who served in the military?


In a shocking new book by Kitty Kelley, acquaintances of President Bush say that when he was in the National Guard that he liked to sneak out back for a joint or go in the bathroom and do cocaine. Isn't that unbelievable? They actually found people who saw Bush in the National Guard. —Jay Leno

Tue May 24, 01:01:59 PM EDT  
 Anonymous blogged...

Perhaps this is the answer. A volunteer army for combat, and a peacekeeping force drafted from the general populace, and trained in cultural studies, diplomacy, etc, to handle the aftermath.

Swell. In the spirit of Star Wars we can call them the Stormtroopers and the Imperial Guard, or we could use an historical allusion and call them the Waffen Schutzstaffel and the Wehrmacht.

- Phoenician in a time of Romans

Tue May 24, 09:31:07 PM EDT  
 DuWayne Brayton blogged...

Dread pirate roberts

Cynical, even downright, but true non the less. My dad has another term for a cynic - realist. Unfortunately it seems quite likely to me that when the easiest way for a poor kid to pay for their education is a G.I. bill then that is exactly the case. And really, it makes sense, I mean why not just educate those you can exert some influence on. Push them into fields like law enforcement or intelligence really (but only if their not terribly) and if not those fields, just tell them to keep an eye on their neighbors, be a good citizen. After all if they have nothing to hide then they shouldn't mind being watched and if they do, well. . . The easiest way to subvert the masses without actually giving them a reasonable standard of living.

Tue May 24, 11:03:50 PM EDT  
 Anonymous blogged...

Excellent post, by all means. My good friend of 5 years and roommate of 2 has decided something that I can’t quite figure out. Quick profile: upper class family (easily in the six digit income), always been fascinated, and I mean fascinated, by war/spy movies and videogames. He joined Army ROTC second semester freshman year. Fine and admirable by me, get your education and come out and serve. My brother did it and is serving right now, so no biggie. Well, no more than 3 weeks ago, he decided to drop ROTC, school, and go enlist. That deserves a big “WTF?” (What the…). There are so many young men and women who would kill for the opportunities he had. Paid education and come out as an officer? You trade that for enlistment? His parents are quite upset, and I know I, along with some of his other friends, are upset, too. And he’s burned down bridges in his wake, so there goes coming back. It makes no sense.

Although it’s no community college, and I can’t compare 2005 with a time period I never saw, I can say what’s happening at this state college. This being a red state, there is still a lingering sense of defeat from the last election amongst those Young Democrats and any would be rebels. Exception- Our letters to the Editor has boiled up some nasty responses by faculty, administration, and the editors themselves. I guess print would be a wonderful way to get the word out, but unfortunately, not many read it. You won’t see much action until they feel the direct consequences instead of reading or hearing about them, i.e. a draft.

Indeed, that is truly when things would start heating up…

lowlyredstater grabs the fire poker.

Wed May 25, 05:42:39 PM EDT  
 DemiOrator blogged...

Mr. Wraith (I'm always the formal one):

I thought this was an extraordinary post. The details you caught were quite vivid and pressed home these deep currents you've observed. I could hear the boasts of young men, smell the cigsmoke. I'm sure I know these men gathered in the common area. I think I used to hang out with some of them. But that's impossible. Decades have passed since then.

The inability, nay, the lack of ability to study, the desire to learn and yet missing the skills needed, not even knowing how to get those skills. There is an ease at being able to sign up, allow something larger than yourself to assume control of huge portions of your life. No, I never served in the military but I think I get at least some of the attraction. Oh, and the weapons are kewl.

Anyway, I liked this very much. Thanks.

Wed May 25, 06:54:45 PM EDT  
 Dark Wraith blogged...

Good evening, Lowly Red Stater.

What your friend did makes all the sense in the world to me. It makes all the sense in the world.

I scored so high on the ASVAB that I could have done anything I wanted. I chose a combat MOS. To this day, I'd rather be outside in the cold, I'd rather be in a crummy diner, I'd rather drive my old Cherokee, I'd rather not be among the better people, I'd rather stitch myself, I'd rather take care of my own want and loneliness and hunger.

It is, in some sub-cultures, what makes the difference between a man and something just slightly less.

At least, that's what we have been made to believe. Experience has indicated to me that it's a good way to live.

And a noble way to die.



The Dark Wraith hopes you understand what is difficult to put into words, Lowly Red Stater.

Wed May 25, 10:37:00 PM EDT  
 Dark Wraith blogged...

Good evening, WordLackey.

Yes, you are correct: there is an ease in signing up. It's something that can be accomplished; and even though basic training is hard, it is a kind of hard that has a clear end-point and almost a kind of assurance that, if you can take the mental and physical abuse, you'll get through, and you'll be on your way.

I am somewhat critical of professors on this point: far too often, I see an almost sneering approach to the ignorance of the students: The little snot will either learn it, or I'll flunk him. There is absolutely no tradition of which the students are aware that, if they keep busting their chops, they'll get through hard coursework. Too many times, I've seen exams at the college level written with the idea that, "Well, I know how to get the answer; and that's all that matters in preparing exams."

I don't like that mentality: it creates a paralyzing fear. Military training, for all I utterly hate about its violence and brutality, carries an implicit message of confidence building exercises. There is too little encouragement and too much presumption that every trainee deserves to be treated like dirt 24/7; but somehow, there's also that message that it's for your own good and for a greater cause.

Academics are too often far too precious to bring their teaching to a focal point of meaning, trial, and passage every day they're in the classroom.

It's a pity that few teachers do this. They'd be amazed at how students respond.

They might also be amazed at how academic administrators would scorn them for teaching that way. Then again, maybe that's why few teachers will try it.


The Dark Wraith, however, doesn't much care what peers and superiors think, these days.

Wed May 25, 10:51:14 PM EDT  
 SB Gypsy blogged...

Dear Dark Wraith,

I found this encouraging blurb in the Boston Globe

"... In recent days, four new polls -- by CBS, Gallup, the Pew Research Center, and Democratic pollster Stanley Greenberg -- have documented just how much the tide has turned.

Bush's approval rating has sagged under 50 percent in all of them, and to the low- to mid-40s in two. The two surveys that asked found that a plurality favor a Democratic Congress or plan to vote for a Democratic congressional candidate next time. -(italics mine)- All four reported strong disapproval of the president's handling of the economy and strong disagreement with his stance on Social Security...."

yes yes yes!



I am wondering if there will be a parallel religious antithesis showing up. I haven't seen much evidence of it, though.

I get the liberal evangelical journal, called "Sojourners"(they send it even if you are a long time pagan, like me), published by Jim Wallis. He has also written a book called "God's Politics : Why the Right Gets It Wrong and the Left Doesn't Get It".

There is a progressive christian movement beginning out there that asks questions about the type of moral values being pimped by this administration, and tries to counter the extream policies being touted as moral in this country now. The newsletter has articles, and suggestions for actions, and coordinates demonstrations.

Needless to say, they do not get much coverage in the msp, although I found him on The Daily Show.

Fri May 27, 02:05:44 PM EDT  
 Anonymous blogged...

If I recall correctly (from 25 years ago when I paid attention) Sojourners does an excellent job of reminding evangelicals about all those annoying "social Gospel" values that are just as much a part of the New Testament as the parts they actually like to read.

- oddjob

Fri May 27, 02:25:05 PM EDT  
 Dark Wraith blogged...

Good afternoon, SB Gypsy.

I am somewhat familiar with Sojourners, although I was under the mistaken impression that the enterprise was pretty much defunct. After I read your comment, I did some digging around and discovered that the group is still active, although well ignored by the mainstream press.

As OddJob noted, Sojourners does have the annoying habit of pointing out the worldly obligations of the faithful. I even noted this idea in economics class in the context of the scathing critique that was being leveled against the Chistian churches by some of the Young Hegelians in the early/mid-19th Century.

What I am waiting to see is if any Christian denominations are going to take the position that the evangelical, extremist cults within Christianity are not, after all, within the Christian religion. Declaring them heretics opens a door to debate on a new level; it also, unfortunately, opens the door to what could ultimately be a violence not merely of words.

Sooner or later, though, someone must ask the question posed by the Jews of thousands of years ago, who had to that point seen their wars against other peoples as battles between gods. At one point, and finally, the question was asked of whether or not these other gods actually even existed.

Sooner or later, the Christians must ask whether or not those who pose as the hateful and purest of the godly might in fact be not just outside of grace, but something altogether other than Christians.


The Dark Wraith believes that this needs to be asked.

Fri May 27, 04:16:20 PM EDT  
 Anonymous blogged...

oddjob agrees, and is reminded of the fatwah issued by mullahs of Spain against Al Qaeda for apostasy, and essentially creating an Islam of its own fashioning, rather than adhering to the real one.

- oddjob

Fri May 27, 04:45:34 PM EDT  
 SB Gypsy blogged...

Good Morning Dark Wraith,

I agree that if what you describe does come about, it would heal alot of wounds, all the while increasing the violence level in this country, and worldwide, for that matter.

Like John Stewart recently said on the Daily Show:

...Moderates do not rise up and march in the streets chanting "let's all be reasonable"


But that's what it's going to take, when it gets down to it. The silent majority, when threatened, rises up and makes it's presence known.

Now we just have to wait for them to realize that the threat to their basic rights and livlihood is worse than the terrorist bugaboo.




...Then we'll see if some convienent "incidents" of the terrorist persuasion happen here on US soil.

Mon May 30, 11:43:59 AM EDT  
 BadTux blogged...

Most of those guys'n'gals in the Army went to the recruiting station for the same reason I went down to the recruiting station 25 years ago: because if you're a poor ghetto kid in East L.A. who wants to get out of that place, or an ambitious cracker girl in Eastern Tennessee who doesn't want to be rendering chickens for the rest of your life, the Army is a damned good way of getting out of that place. You get to see the world, you get to learn about discipline and hard work and other values that will serve you well once you get out and are in the civilian world, you get decent though not extravagant benefits upon getting out...

Let's face it, if you were born in the bottomlands, those places where the American dream died long ago and the hole where the dream once was is now largely filled by hatred and violence and drugs and alcohol, and you're a bright young boy or girl who sees just how fucked up this place is, you will do literally anything to escape the bottomlands. Even if it could literally kill you. Because being killed in the OTHER money-making profession for bright people in the bottomlands (drug dealing) is just as possible, and the long term prospects are considerably dimmer than in a peacetime Army. When I walked up to that recruiting station, I knew that Ronnie Ray-gun was a right-wing nutcase and that there was a good chance that I'd end up in a war and could get killed. But the alternatives weren't any better.

The sad thing is, even today, when these kids know they stand a good chance of dying in Iraq, they still see no choice other than the recruiting station... what kind of nation are we, that this is the only choice we can give so many young people?

-- Badtux the Military Penguin

Wed Jun 01, 03:12:17 AM EDT  
 charliepotato blogged...

Hi DW,

This article sneaked by me, however you made mention of it today in Nightbirds Fountain and having read it I felt the need to remark on it's chilling parallel to my little community. Between our community college and our closed down business's the picture is bleak for many and many ghosts of the past remain. The Bushco prey on these disadvantaged children as they constantly need to replace those in their war machine ranks because those within have seen the error of their ways.

charliepotato

Wed Jan 25, 08:02:20 AM EST